The Great Debate...

[slowro]

Flame or Quilt
I'm a flame man myself :top:

[rugerpc]

I gotta choose one only???!!? I won't. You can't make me.

I want both

and a standard

or 2

hell - I'll take them all. Just hook them up to your computers and shove them through the interweb...

[slowro]

yup only ONE ahaha
am I evil? :rofl::rofl::rofl:

[andy474x]

I'll take all those quilts no one wants!

[QueenCityGuitars]

Quilt. :rock:

[veinbuster]

I've been on a quilt kick for a few years, so voted that way, but to be honest I think I'll try a flame again the next time I get a guitar - that is as long as I can avoid seeing a certain double sided HB quilt first.

[hemantooth]

Big wide flame please.

[Herr Squid]

Quilt all the way!!!

[markie]

Flipflopper here....................:dontknow:

[crgtr]

Flame job for me!

[Jester]

Like asking Blond or Brunette, the only answer is both.

If I really had to pick, it would be quilt.

[]-[ @ n $ 0 |v| a T ! ©]

Quilt all the way!!!
Have I mentioned how cool that avatar is (lately) Dave? ;)


Flipflopper here....................:dontknow:
I guess I'm in the same boat. I tend to think that I prefer quilt but then I put flame on my PS.

It just depends on the guitar.

[wilerty]

Of those choices, I pick flame, but on my PS I chose one piece burl.

[sergiodeblanc]

I'm a flamer.

[Buildermike]

I love quilts on other people guitars. Out of my double digit collection I only own two quilts, one production and one custom build where I chose. Everything else are flame tops. I can't explain but when it's time to pull the wallet out, flame wins out.

[Harker1440]

FIRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Twinfan]

Big wide flame please.

Same for me please.

[Mike Duncan]

Flame on.


though being an opaque lover...

[DirtyMoonsRJT]

I've been on a quilt kick for a few years, so voted that way, but to be honest I think I'll try a flame again the next time I get a guitar - that is as long as I can avoid seeing a certain double sided HB quilt first.


Umm you have a spalted???? One of the most badass guitars I have ever seen if I remember correctly!



i voted flame.....but I like uniqueness .....mineral streaks, etc to give it character.

[DirtyMoonsRJT]

I love quilts on other people guitars. Out of my double digit collection I only own two quilts, one production and one custom build where I chose. Everything else are flame tops. I can't explain but when it's time to pull the wallet out, flame wins out.

And If its the one im thinking about a fine custom build it is!!! Feel free to let me know if you ever decide you would rather add more flame and part with that one!

[prscat33511]

Quilt for sure
looks like phosphorescent water ripples

[solacematt]

flame, the quilt tops just look ridiculous to me

[Goldtop]

I honestly have no preference either way. If it isn't a Goldtop :-) , then I like a top that has what I consider a nice character about it. By that I mean not too perfect, not too symmetrical in the bookmatching. Having as many lines and fibers as possible line up just so is something that I know is paramount to some people, but not to me. As long as the center seam is done correctly, then any other aspects of a top will probably be fine by me.

And first and foremost to me, above all else, is the sound, feel, build quality, etc.

Goldtop

[Fbrandw]

Tight chevron flame all the way!

[LSchefman]

I've had some nice quilts over the years, but I tend to go for flame tops.

[Herr Squid]

-[ @ n $ 0 |v| a T ! ©;31705']Have I mentioned how cool that avatar is (lately) Dave? ;)



Nope! But heck, how often have I given you an opportunity by posting lately?

[jfb]

Flame as wide as wide can be with some chevron!!

[]-[ @ n $ 0 |v| a T ! ©]

Nope! But heck, how often have I given you an opportunity by posting lately?
Perhaps you'll give me a few more?

Pick a card, brother.

[JMintzer]

Flilt...


Jamie

[justmund]

Quilt, I like the uniqueness every one offers

[Rango]

I've tried to like quilt - I even owned a very nice one.... a VERY nice one.
http://i976.photobucket.com/albums/ae245/Chutist/9f48ffec.jpg

They just don't work for me....The one's "quilt guys" go bonkers for? Look like the background on a bad velvet Elvis painting at some garage sale... ;)

Always liked FLAME - Flame maple tops and necks just do it for me. :D
This guitar will pop up used some day and I'm going to grab it! Flame top and Flame neck!
http://i976.photobucket.com/albums/ae245/Chutist/7985351333_e65d6e957c_b.jpg

But it's all good - the guys that like quilt are not trying to scoop up my prized flame wood and I'm not after their velvet. WIN WIN! :p

[11top]

I love good quilt (especially tubular), but there's something about a deep chevron book matched fiddleback.

[Herr Squid]

-[ @ n $ 0 |v| a T ! ©;31824']Perhaps you'll give me a few more?

Pick a card, brother.

Whoa. That's a big scary commitment for a timid woodland creature like me!